nobody has ever won a grievance
You sit on a board and watch the chair give the chief executive an ultimatum: accept a settlement, or be suspended. The deadline to accept passes, and within days the chief executive is suspended.
The board then commissions an independent review, at the chair's urging, into the chief executive's conduct; it finds no case to answer. A separate investigation into how the chair handled the matter finds that she exceeded her authority.
Sides were taken, but nobody won. Both of them leave quietly.
What is left is two empty chairs, a stunned silence, and a board meeting on Monday that you are expected to attend, with the responsibility for what happens next now sitting with you.
Your organisation almost certainly has a policy, a portal, and a timeline for every grievance a person can raise, each one built to produce a result: a winner and a loser, a claim upheld or dismissed. What none of them can tell you is why, when the result finally lands, no one in the room feels like they have won.
A grievance process can tell you that you were right. What it cannot do is make you whole; what it can do is make a finding of fact. So being right and being told you were right converge in a verdict that leaves you exactly where losing would have. The strongest finding the grievance process can yield is to be cleared. And yet, your chief executive left the role anyway.
So, for a while, you and the remaining directors bumble on, wondering whether everyone has simply become more polite, while decisions pile up and challenge quietly disappears. Everyone has drawn the same lesson from watching two senior colleagues undone by a process: you may be next. With that realisation, the resignations begin, one at a time, each with no more than a knowing look at the directors left behind.
Repair starts the moment after the findings land. It means sitting down with each director individually to hear what they saw and what they have not felt safe or brave enough to say since. It means bringing them back together to name what the back-to-back investigations did to them: what was said, what was assumed, and what has quietly changed between them. It means agreeing out loud how the board will disagree the next time it is forced to.
Most boards do not recover from situations like these on their own. The willingness to put it right has to come from within the room; only then can someone from outside it help you rebuild.
If your board has won the argument and lost the room, it might be time to look outside the room for assistance. Email us on [email protected]
The WayFinders Group deals with the elephant(s) in the room after an investigation, inquiry, or tribunal, when the findings land 🐘
repair on home turf
📖 I've got a book coming in 2028, and this one is close to home. It takes the work you read about here each week, repairing an institution after the worst has happened, and turns it on the church; on what is owed to the people its scandals have left behind. That is all I'll say for now.
The full announcement is coming, and it is a big one.
You may have clocked the adverts we run each week and thought your brand could do better in that slot, you are probably right! The Fixer reaches over 6,500 chairs, chief executives, and governance advisers every Friday, one in two of them open it, and the list grows every week. If you would like them looking at your brand instead, reply to this email.
your (reframed) watchlist 🔍
In the week where Guardian journalists were told they could work from home while bedbugs were cleared from the King's Cross newsroom, talks on returning the Elgin Marbles to Greece collapsed after five years because neither side would give ground on who owns them, TalkTalk was reported to be days from administration after both of its sale deals stalled, and the Insolvency Service announced its first prosecutions of directors who had not verified their identity with Companies House, the question is how long a problem can sit in the building before someone admits it is there.
investigation of the week🕵🏽♀️
Ofcom has opened an investigation into whether Pornhub's owner, Aylo, tested Apple's age checks properly before relying on them to keep children off the site. Outsourcing a safeguard also outsources the knowledge of whether it works.
tribunal finding of the week 👩🏾⚖️
A lead auditor at ANS Group was awarded £31,725 after her manager belittled her, took credit for her work, and kept her working while she was in hospital with suspected TB. The company decided the manager needed training only after she had gone.
regulator of the week 👸🏽
The Charity Commission has issued Save the Children International with an official warning over its Yemen office, citing weak oversight, whistleblower complaints that were never escalated, and a negative working culture.
boardroom drama of the week👩🏽🔧
The Competition and Markets Authority fined M&J Group and two of its staff £50,000 after a director told the office manager to take a work phone and paperwork off the premises during a dawn raid, then told officers he had no work phone. She was fined £5,000 for doing as she was asked.
shareholder revolt of the week ⚔️
At Games Workshop's AGM, 15.67% (that’s 1 in 6) shareholders voted against re-electing director Mark Lam.
did you know 💡
Since 1 September 2026, the FCA's conduct rules have treated bullying and harassment as misconduct at almost every financial services firm, where before they applied only to banks. How colleagues treat each other is now a matter for the regulator.
Leah Brown FRSA is Britain’s leading workplace repair expert, fixing the things everyone else would rather sweep under the rug 🧹



