Two childhoods walk into a boardroom. Nobody sees them arrive. The chair does not know what they are, the directors sitting either side cannot name them, and the two people carrying them have, for the most part, no idea they are there. They both take their seats.

The first childhood grew up in a house where you did not question the person at the head of the table, and silence was the price of things staying calm. That compliant nature travelled into adulthood the way an accent does, and today it sits inside a director who does not experience her silence as silence. She experiences it as being reasonable rather than hypervigilant; as choosing her battles and reading the room effectively.

The second childhood grew up in the same kind of house but was wounded by it. He made a vow he would never sit quietly while something wrong happened in front of him. Inside this director are convictions that have been hard won. He does not experience his persistence as aggression but rather as the value he adds in the room.

When you put these two childhoods at the same table, eventually a paper will surface. The first childhood lets it go, but the second cannot, and asks seemingly disruptive questions in a tone the minutes will later reflect as a “robust discussion”. In the meantime everyone else in the room gets uncomfortable as the paper surfaces emotions that are no longer about the words on the page. 

Sometimes the second childhood does not hold a seat at the table. Sometimes it stands outside the room and asks to be invited in. This week, 87.5 per cent of voting Nationwide members rejected James Sherwin-Smith, the first member-nominated candidate in more than twenty years. Nine million people who bank there could have voted. Fewer than 620,000 did. 

A mutual's owners are millions of people with a current account. Many of them have no interest in the boardroom with oversight over their investments. So when the director driven by internal convictions keeps asking questions, it is fair to presume nobody outside the room is aware he is advocating for them. He can only keep asking, in a room that has already decided he is difficult, until he stops or leaves. And the director who keeps the peace has never been safer, because the thing she did not say will never surface. In a room nobody watches, staying quiet is what a sensible person does.

Give it a year. He is isolated, then absent. She remains quiet, and everyone who saw what happened to him adopts the same posture. From the inside, it looks like the meetings have become easier. What has gone is the one voice that tested what everyone else assumed.

A new chair does not fix the fallout here, because nothing is wrong with the appointments process. The fracture isn’t between two people but between the expectations communicated and the behaviours demonstrated in the boardroom. Repair, therefore, isn’t a mediation between the silent and the vocal, but rather a conversation in which each director is invited to consider what is at stake, what each of them has been protecting, and what should have happened. 

Look around your own table. You know who keeps the peace. You know who asks all the questions. You may even be a bit of both yourself. But one thing is clear: allowing the dissenting voice to disengage is more dangerous than facing its difficult questions. These are conditions that need to be repaired before they derail your board. Repair is always an invitation.

Start today:  [email protected].

ICYMI: Every organisation stands for something and communicates it publicly. The test is what it does when standing by that becomes costly or embarrassing. The entries below are this week's examples of organisations meeting that test or failing it. When one fails, the behaviour and the promise are moving in opposite directions, which creates damage that does not fix itself of its own accord.

⬆ Up (who hit the mark this week)

The Pensions Regulator published a five-year strategy and a regulatory roadmap, pivoting from building pension pots to sustainable income in retirement and promising trustees a "no surprises" line of sight. 

The Care Quality Commission published its first national picture of adult social care across 143 local authority assessments: 3 per cent outstanding, 60 per cent good, 35 per cent requires improvement, and 78 per cent scoring 1 or 2 on needs assessment.

The Gambling Commission entered into a settlement with Evolution AB  for £4.75m after its live casino content reached British consumers via two unlicensed operators it had already terminated on discovering the problem.

⬇ Down (who missed the mark this week)

British Steel went into public ownership on Thursday, the day after Royal Assent, fifteen months after Parliament was recalled on a Saturday to stop Jingye closing the Scunthorpe furnaces. The National Audit Office puts the running cost at £1.3m a day with no budget, no repayment schedule, and no end date; compensation for Jingye is still unsettled and the regulations don't arrive until autumn.

The Environment Agency's performance assessment is the worst since it began. England's nine water and sewerage companies scored 19 stars out of 36, with serious incidents up 60 per cent and Thames, Southern and Yorkshire responsible for 81 per cent of them. 

The Charity Commission seized £819,494 from the We Care Foundation, under statutory inquiry since January 2024 over unexplained payments to trustees and companies they direct. Nearly £19,000 of the frozen money has gone on paying one of the interim managers brought in to replace them. 

The Care Quality Commission rated urgent and emergency care at Royal United Hospital Bath requires improvement, finding three regulatory breaches on safe care, staffing, and management after an inspection prompted by complaints about overcrowding.

👁 Watch (who we're watching this week)

Rank Group has offered the Gambling Commission £5m in lieu of a penalty over historical compliance failings at Grosvenor Casinos, and the Commission is minded to accept. The finalisation letter hasn't landed; preliminary results are due 13 August.

The Water Regulation Bill is moving through the Lords and would abolish Ofwat, folding economic, environmental, and drinking water regulation into one Clean Water Authority. The biggest restructure since 1989, arriving the same month the sector posted its worst environmental score on record. 

Hillsborough Law cleared all its Commons stages on Tuesday, passing third reading unanimously.

In September I will be speaking at Ogilvy's Nudgestock, on the same bill as Louis Theroux and Matt Hancock 👀, on thinking differently about trust. It follows my recent run of rooms where repair has been the question on the table: an independent school, the UK Mediation Conference, the Restorative Justice Council's CPD symposium, and our own Chamber of Commerce this very morning. Different audiences, same discovery; everyone recognises the damage once you point it out, and almost nobody knows how to make things better than they were before.

James Watt tabled a bid to buy back BrewDog, promising 43,000 wiped-out Equity Punks their shares back for free after running the company into administration. Tilray bought the assets legitimately and owes the Equity Punks nothing. 

The dilemma: you are one of the Equity Punks. The man whose decisions wiped out your shares is offering them back for free. He has already apologised. Do you trust him to do what he says he will do?

Researching accounts. Building lists. Writing sequences.

There's a better use of your team's time.

Apollo is the AI revenue engine that handles the busywork, so you can stay focused on selling.

Plus, everything you need is in one place:

Stop doing busywork and start building pipeline, faster.

With Apollo — the AI revenue engine powering 4M+ users.

Sign up for free

Leah Brown FRSA is Britain’s leading workplace repair expert, restoring your organisation's capacity to do what it said it would do.